Exuma is not a single resort town with one beach and a strip of hotels. It is a long chain of cays in The Bahamas, and the island you sleep on will shape almost every day of the trip. Get the base right first; the villa or hotel comes second.
Most visitors choose Great Exuma, especially around George Town; quieter Little Exuma just across the bridge; or Staniel Cay and the central Exuma Cays. A smaller number look at Stocking Island, or at private-island stays such as Fowl Cay and Compass Cay.
Some links on this page may be affiliate links. If you book through them, Exuma by Design may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. If you use our trip-planning form, we may earn a referral fee when a trip is booked. See the affiliate disclosure.
The short version
- Great Exuma, for the main airport, more restaurants, and a wider mix of hotels and villas — plus a longer boat day if you want the swimming pigs.
- Little Exuma, for a slower feel and easy access to Tropic of Cancer Beach, usually in a villa, still connected by road to George Town and the airport.
- Staniel Cay, if the cays are the point of the trip — pigs, Thunderball Grotto, sandbars, and nurse sharks — and you can accept tighter lodging and a different arrival than flying into Exuma International Airport (GGT).
- Stocking Island, if you want to sleep across Elizabeth Harbour from George Town, with a short boat shuttle instead of a rental car.
- Compass Cay or Fowl Cay, for a private-island base in the central cays. Arrival is by air into Staniel Cay, or by boat, and inventory is limited.
Great Exuma and George Town: the practical base
Great Exuma is the main inhabited island in the chain, and George Town is its hub. Exuma International Airport sits here, which is why so many first visits should start on this island. You can land, collect a car or a transfer, and reach your stay without a second flight on day one.
George Town wraps around Elizabeth Harbour, whose deep water has long drawn sailors, and around Lake Victoria in the middle of town. It is a working Bahamian settlement, with a pastel Government Building and harbor-side restaurants, not a purpose-built resort village.
This is the easiest place to have a mixed trip: a beach morning, lunch in or near town, and a full-day boat excursion when you want the cays. The tradeoff is simple. The swimming pigs live at Big Major Cay, near Staniel Cay, so a visit from George Town is a long day on the water. If you want the pigs and the grotto close every morning, look north instead.
The town changes character during the National Family Island Regatta, held here each year, typically in April. Book early if you want the sloops and waterfront crowds; choose other dates for a calmer week, and confirm the current schedule on the official regatta site. Beyond town, Queen’s Highway runs the length of a long, lightly built island, which is why a rental car is useful for many stays. Hooper’s Bay, Emerald Bay, and Roker’s Point are often mentioned. Read a map and recent guest photos: “ocean view” is not always steps into the water you saw in a photograph.
Resort, hotel, and villa examples on Great Exuma
Confirm that any property is open for your dates before you treat it as a plan.
Villa resorts suit couples and families who want a kitchen and a resort beach without running a whole private house. Grand Isle Resort & Residences, at Roker’s Point on Emerald Bay, offers one- to four-bedroom villas and penthouses, plus on-site dining and the Emerald Bay shoreline. Check prices on Expedia, or check prices on Booking.com.
Harbor-front hotels in George Town are useful if you want to walk to dinner. Peace & Plenty is a long-established hotel in town, with harbor-view rooms and a beach club and villas on Stocking Island. Check prices on Booking.com, or check prices on Expedia.
February Point, near George Town, is a private marina community with vacation rentals and beach access, a good fit if you arrive by boat or want to be around the docks. Access rules can differ from a conventional hotel, so read the rental details carefully. Check prices, or ask us for an introduction to a local manager.
Private villas along the coasts of Great Exuma are often the heart of a more designed week: a house with a pool, a cook or a pre-stocked kitchen, and enough bedrooms for a family or friends. Many of the best houses are managed locally and may not appear completely, or at the best rate, on the large sites. Check prices on Vrbo, check prices on Booking.com, or plan your trip with us.
One property not to assume is open: the former Sandals Emerald Bay closed to guests in August 2024 for a planned conversion. A confirmed reopening date was not available when this guide was written. Wait for the official brand site to accept reservations.
Little Exuma: quieter, still connected
Little Exuma sits just south of Great Exuma and is linked by a short bridge, so the airport and George Town stay within reach by road. What you buy is atmosphere: fewer services and some of the chain’s prettiest open beaches.
Tropic of Cancer Beach — also known as Pelican Beach — is the postcard many people picture when they want “that Exuma water.” The Tropic of Cancer line crosses this shore; a marker on the approach is a favorite photo stop. If your group is happy cooking in and spending long hours on the sand, a villa here is often a better match than a hotel in town.
Evenings here tend to be about sunsets and a slow dinner; for a livelier meal, head back toward George Town. Inventory is thinner and more house-driven than hotel-driven, so book early, especially for winter and holiday weeks. Check prices on Vrbo, or check prices on Booking.com. For help narrowing a short list, plan your trip with us.
Stocking Island: across the harbor
Stocking Island lies across Elizabeth Harbour from George Town. You are on a quieter strip of land, often with a beach close at hand, and you get to town by boat rather than by car. Some visitors love that immediately; others miss having a car.
A day trip is one of the easiest pleasures of a stay in town. Water taxis connect the town waterfront to the island, and Chat ’N’ Chill is a well-known beach bar, where stingrays often appear in the shallows. A stay commits you to that boat-first rhythm. Peace & Plenty’s Stocking Island villas and beach club are a long-standing example. Read how transfers from GGT and dinner in town actually work. Check prices, or ask us to compare a harbor hotel with an island cottage.
Staniel Cay and the central Exuma Cays
Stay in the cays when the water is the trip. Staniel Cay is the best-known small-island base near Big Major Cay, home of the swimming pigs, Thunderball Grotto just west of the cay, and the sandbars people fly a long way to photograph. The island is small, and days turn on boats and tides.
Lodging is limited compared with Great Exuma, and it can book out in winter. Many people fly into Nassau and connect to Staniel Cay Airport (TYM), or they fly from Fort Lauderdale Executive Airport (FXE) on a scheduled island hop. Others visit on a day trip from Great Exuma. See Getting to Exuma for the practical details.
Staniel Cay Yacht Club is the best-known address, with waterfront bungalows, a villa, a marina, and a restaurant that has long been the island’s gathering place. Check the official site as well as the large booking platforms; some stays include a skiff or meal plan. Check prices on Expedia, or check prices on Booking.com.
If you are based on Great Exuma and still want a pigs-and-grotto day, book a reputable full-day tour in advance and leave a weather buffer. Check prices on Viator, or check prices on GetYourGuide. If your dream week is three or four boat days in the cays, base here if you can get the right room. If you want a house, restaurants, a car, and one spectacular cays day, Great Exuma or Little Exuma will probably make you happier.
Compass Cay, Fowl Cay, and other private-island stays
North of Staniel Cay, Compass Cay is famous first as a marina stop, where visitors swim with the resident nurse sharks, and second as a small lodging base. The marina’s official site lists houses and cottages, including Lilly’s Villa, The Lodge, Crescent Beach House, and Buttonwood Bungalow, typically rented with a kitchen. Availability changes by season, so confirm a current listing. Check prices, or plan your trip with us.
Fowl Cay is a private-island resort in the same stretch of the chain, with six oceanfront villas. The official site describes an all-inclusive stay that includes meals and drinks, a powerboat with fuel, water-sports and fishing gear, a golf cart, and housekeeping. It sits close to Big Major Cay and a short boat ride from Thunderball Grotto and Staniel Cay. Inquire on the official site, or ask us to compare it with a Staniel Cay bungalow or a Great Exuma villa.
Hotels and resorts versus villas
Choose a hotel or villa resort if you want on-site dining, a front desk, and fewer logistics — the lower-stress path for a first visit or a shorter stay.
Choose a private villa if you have a group, want a kitchen and a pool you do not share, or are celebrating something. Villas reward a little more planning: transfers, groceries, a boat day reserved in advance, and a clear sense of what staff is included. If you would rather not assemble that yourself, use the Plan your trip form.
Compare free-cancellation rates against a slightly cheaper non-refundable price. Winter, spring break, and holiday weeks move first. Check prices on a Booking.com map of Exuma, check prices for Expedia hotels, and check prices for Vrbo houses. If two platforms show the same property, open both before you pay.
What to double-check before you book
- Open or closed. Island properties renovate or pause bookings. Open the official site, not only a listing card, before you book.
- Where the beach actually is. Read the map and recent guest photos, not only the hero shot.
- How you will get around. Some stays need a rental car; others work better with a reserved transfer and pre-booked boat days. Check prices for rental cars at GGT. See Getting to Exuma for taxis and Staniel Cay arrivals.
- The pigs question. If the swimming pigs are non-negotiable, base near Staniel Cay or book a reputable full-day tour from Great Exuma before you arrive, and leave a weather buffer. Check prices for tours.
- Insurance. Compare a travel-insurance policy against the lodging cancellation terms. Check prices for travel insurance.
A simple way to decide this week
If you land at GGT, want restaurants and options, and will take one big cays day trip, stay on Great Exuma. If you want a house, a quieter road, and Tropic of Cancer Beach as your default afternoon, look at Little Exuma. If the cays are the whole point, stay on Staniel Cay, or consider Compass Cay or Fowl Cay. If you want the harbor without a car, look at Stocking Island and read the boat-transfer fine print.
If you already know you want a villa for a wedding week, a family house, or a honeymoon, tell us the dates, the group, and the budget. Plan your trip with us. We will come back with a short list.
Next: Getting to Exuma, Things to Do in Exuma, and Best Beaches in Exuma.